The article centers on a long-standing dispute between former St Kilda players, led by Barry Breen, and the club, concerning a 1984 financial settlement. The AFL and St Kilda initially attempted to keep the $300,000 settlement secret, and several key figures refused to comment publicly.
Breen, along with other former teammates, felt they were unfairly compensated and remained disenchanted with both the club and the AFL Players’ Association (AFLPA). He highlights the sacrifices he made for the club, resulting in significant financial losses. While he acknowledges the recent settlement as a step toward recognition, he retains his criticism of certain individuals involved.
The AFL and AFLPA's roles are scrutinized. The AFL's reluctance to publicly address the situation and their funding of the AFLPA are questioned. The AFLPA's response is deemed insufficient by Breen and his former teammates.
Despite the recent payouts, Breen's discontent with certain individuals remains. While he has reached a level of peace regarding the situation, the article underscores the lingering feelings of injustice among former players and the significant financial implications of the original agreement. The event at the MCG to raise funds further emphasizes the club's complex past and reconciliation attempts.