This article contrasts the United States' strong free speech traditions with the United Kingdom's perceived decline in civil liberties. It highlights the arrest of Graham Linehan in the UK for online comments as a stark example of this contrast.
Graham Linehan, an Irish comedian, was arrested and faces charges for allegedly hurtful online statements. This incident, viewed with incredulity in the US, underscores the differing approaches to free speech.
Nigel Farage testified before the House Judiciary Committee in Washington concerning the potential impact of the UK's Online Safety Bill. This bill is seen as a potential threat to free speech, particularly impacting US-owned platforms.
The article notes growing concern in the US about the erosion of free speech and civil liberties in the UK, citing statements from US Vice President JD Vance and a US State Department report. American citizens are increasingly questioning the UK's direction.
The author draws comparisons between the US and UK, contrasting their approaches to immigration, crime, energy policy, and economic management. The UK is depicted as having a high-tax economy, social unrest, and declining civil liberties, in stark contrast to the US.
The core difference is highlighted as a philosophical divide: the US upholding the principles of Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness, while the UK is seen as sinking into a socialist quagmire. This contrast is illustrated by comparing the reactions to wealth and success in both countries.
The author expresses pessimism about the future of free speech in the UK, predicting continued suppression of dissenting voices. The Online Safety Bill is seen as a tool that will exacerbate the situation.
Published: 12:39 EDT, 4 September 2025 | Updated: 13:51 EDT, 4 September 2025
Echoing the Daily Mailâs front page on Wednesday, Nigel Farage lamented the state of free speech in Britain. âAt what point did we become North Korea?â
Heâd been invited to give evidence to the House Judiciary Committee in Washington about the potential impact of British and European laws designed to curb what can be said online.
As Farage flew out to the US, Graham Linehan flew in â to be detained at the airport by five armed police officers over some allegedly hurty words heâd posted on the internet months ago.
Linehanâs arrest followed a complaint by a militant trans activist. The details of his ordeal have been well documented. He was treated like a terrorist suspect and had to be given emergency medical care when his blood pressure went through the roof. Linehan now faces a police investigation for inciting violence.
He also appeared in court yesterday charged with harassment. The case is continuing.
All this has been greeted with incredulity in America, which has a proud tradition of free speech. The arrest of Linehan, an Irish citizen, happened to coincide with the Reform UK leader being asked to address lawmakers in Washington about the implications of the UKâs Online Safety Bill, which will severely restrict content published on US-owned platforms such as Facebook and whatever Twitter calls itself this week.
Farage warned: âThis could happen to any American man or woman that goes to Heathrow but has said things online that the British government and the British police donât like. It is a potentially big threat to big tech bosses and many, many others.â
You can imagine the jubilation among the far-Left as Elon Musk is hauled off his private jet by armed coppers when he lands in Britain to launch the latest Tesla model.
Reform UK Leader Nigel Farage testifies before the House Judiciary Committee in Washington
Despite the disingenuous back-pedalling by Surkeir and the hapless Met chief Mark Rowley, there remains a very real possibility of that happening in future.
If they can nick an Irish comedy writer for wrongthink, whatâs to stop them feeling the collar of one of Silicon Valleyâs tech bosses on arrival?
Concern about the suppression of free speech in the UK has been mounting in America since the re-election of the Anglophile Donald Trump. Back in February, Vice President JD Vance delivered a damning speech about the erosion of civil liberties and contempt for popular democracy on our side of the pond.
As I observed a few weeks ago, Trump and Vance seem to care more about the UK than our hopeless, deluded Labour government.
On everything from Net Zero and defence to immigration and crime they make a great deal more sense than most of the Westminster Bubbleâs arrogant, out-of-touch political class.
A recent report from the US State Department accused Britain of backsliding on human rights â especially freedom of speech and the frightening rise in anti-Semitism.
Civil liberties are under assault everywhere, from the policeâs obsession with online âhate speechâ to the determination to make ill-defined âIslamophobiaâ a criminal offence, an oppressive blasphemy law by the back door.
Farage rightly warns that the Online Safety Bill will not only curb free speech it could also do serious damage to our trade relations with the US.
Trump and Vance seem to care more about the UK than our hopeless, deluded Labour government
He told the committee: âIt doesnât give me any great joy to be sitting in America and describing the really awful authoritarian situation we have sunk into.â
But donât think for a moment that the state of play in Britain is merely the latest obsession of the New York Times, (the US version of the Guardian), Fox News and the political class.
This has permeated way beyond the Washington Beltway, the US equivalent of the Westminster Bubble. Middle America is paying attention.
Itâs no secret that I spend time every year in the States, where my family ties go back to the 1960s. Everywhere Iâve been this summer, Iâve been asked: âWhat the hell is going in your country?â
I donât mix in political circles. These are questions from regular folk, long-standing friends from all walks of life, and even strangers in bars who clock the accent.
They donât all buy into the romanticised view peddled by the latest Downton Abbey movie, which had its premiere this week. But they have always considered Britain to be the civilised Mother Country, crucible of liberty.
Yet on the nightly news they see images of social breakdown in Britain â rowdy demos outside migrant hotels and the flotillas of small boats landing daily. While Trump has just about halted all illegal migration on the Southern border, the numbers of illegals arriving in Britain â given four-star board and lodging â hits record levels.
They see pro-Hamas marchers effectively chanting âDeath to the Jewsâ with a police escort, while Surkeir stops military exports to Israel and agrees to recognise a Palestinian state without a single hostage being released.
Graham Linehan at Westminster Magistrates' Court today, where he appears charged with harassment
They hear of grooming gangs allowed to operate with impunity for years, violent crime, shoplifting, stabbings, phone thefts on the streets of London, just like New York in the 1970s. Yet while Trump sends the National Guard to reclaim the streets of DC and other crime-ridden cities, the British bobbies are withdrawing from the streets to concentrate on nicking men like Linehan for online âhate crimesâ.
Those who pay closer attention are aware that Britain is a high-tax economic basket case, which may soon need a bail-out from the IMF, with half the country living on benefits.
But while Trump continues to Drill, Baby, Drill, and makes the US not just energy self-sufficient but a net exporter, the British Labour government shuts down oil and gas production and pours concrete into fracking sites so they can never be exploited. They ask themselves â and me â why do these guys have an economic death wish?
And, as proud citizens of a sovereign nation, they canât understand why Surkeir is trying to undo Brexit and drag Britain back into the sclerotic EU.
Thatâs before they hear of us granting special visas to Turkish drag queens working as escorts on the grounds that they have unique âglobal talentâ.
Frankly, I have never known a time when the gap between our two nations has been wider. While Americans are still wedded to Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness, Britain is sinking ever deeper into a bitter, socialist quagmire.
Julian Fellowes, Downtonâs creator, nailed it this week when he said the British hate the rich. Rachel from Complaints is busy drawing up fresh plans to soak anyone who has done well in life through their own efforts, egged on by resentful Labour backbenchers.
In contrast, Americans admire those who have made their own money and aspire to emulate them. I will always remember standing outside a dockside restaurant in Florida with my late father, 40-odd years ago.
As a swanky yacht pulled up, I heard a young man nearby say: âWow, Iâm going to have one like that some day.â In Britain, that same young man would have scowled and said: âWhatâs that rich bastard done to deserve a boat like this?â
Itâs often said that we are two countries divided by a common language. But itâs more than that. Weâre divided philosophically, too.
Take the Linehan case. Freedom of speech is written into the US Constitution. The notion that a comedy writer could be arrested in America for upsetting someone on Twitter is unthinkable.
But the idea that we have ever had freedom of expression in Britain, certainly in my lifetime, is a fiction.
Yes, itâs got ten times worse as the grievance/victim/cancel culture has become institutionalised and weaponised to suppress those who dissent against fashionable far-Left opinion.
But we have long had some of the worldâs most draconian libel laws.
What we can broadcast and print is curtailed by a standing bureaucracy, including Ofcom and IPSO, the newspaper complaints watchdog. There would never have been a Leveson Inquisition into the Press in the US.
Social media pile-ons discourage people from expressing their true opinions, fearful of having their lives and careers ruined.
The Online Safety Bill will exacerbate things still further. The exponential pace of our descent into authoritarianism has been staggering.
Farage ended his evidence in Washington on a upbeat note. He said the UK had âlost its wayâ but was confident common sense would return â especially if he becomes Prime Minister. Letâs hope so, but I donât share his optimism.
Whatever the outcome of his court case, Linehan wonât be the last to fall foul of the free-speech police. Those who dare to criticise the far-Left orthodoxy, on everything from trans rights to illegal immigration, will continue to be harassed, demonised, persecuted and, no doubt, prosecuted.
In the wake of the Ginge Rayner stamp duty expose, how long before it becomes a criminal offence to investigate a politicianâs personal tax affairs?
We need a bonfire of all restrictions of free speech. But it ainât gonna happen.Â
The immediate threat might ease off for a while, but anyone expecting a permanent retreat will be disappointed. These things are a ratchet, not a pendulum. North Korea, here we come.
If you often open multiple tabs and struggle to keep track of them, Tabs Reminder is the solution you need. Tabs Reminder lets you set reminders for tabs so you can close them and get notified about them later. Never lose track of important tabs again with Tabs Reminder!
Try our Chrome extension today!
Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more