Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the Health and Human Services Secretary, proposed barring government scientists from publishing in leading medical journals like The Lancet, New England Journal of Medicine, and JAMA, citing corruption concerns and pharmaceutical influence. He intends to establish in-house publications, claiming they would become the gold standard due to NIH funding implications.
Adam Gaffney, a public health researcher at Harvard Medical School, criticized the proposal, arguing that it would delegitimize taxpayer-funded research. He pointed out that current drug approvals are based on sound science and that while safeguards against commercial influence are necessary, the current political climate, with budget cuts and Kennedy's anti-vaccine stance, makes this unlikely to succeed. The proposal follows Kennedy's unilateral decision to halt coronavirus vaccine recommendations for healthy children and pregnant women, bypassing the CDC.
This action is part of a broader pattern of attacks on scientific institutions by the Trump administration. The "MAHA Report," released by the administration, challenges mainstream medical consensus, prompting criticism for misleading representations of scientific findings. An unusual letter from the U.S. attorney to the journal "Chest" raised free-speech concerns, and significant cuts to NIH funding have led top universities to lose funding and American researchers to consider moving abroad.
These actions, including a purge of around 20,000 federal workers at HHS, have raised serious concerns about the undermining of U.S. scientific research and the integrity of scientific publishing.
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said Tuesday that he may bar government scientists from publishing in the world’s leading medical journals, instead proposing the creation of “in-house” publications by his agency — the latest in the Trump administration’s attacks on scientific institutions.
“We’re probably going to stop publishing in the Lancet, New England Journal of Medicine, JAMA and those other journals because they’re all corrupt,” Kennedy said during an appearance on the “Ultimate Human” podcast. He also described the journals as being under the control of pharmaceutical companies.
The three journals he named, all established in the 1800s, publish original, peer-reviewed research and play a central role in disseminating medical findings worldwide. JAMA, published by the American Medical Association, and the Lancet each say they receive more than 30 million annual visits to their sites, while the New England Journal of Medicine says it is read in print and online by more than 1 million people each week.
The journals did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Kennedy’s remarks.
Kennedy also accused several agencies under the Department of Health and Human Services — including the National Institutes of Health, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Food and Drug Administration, and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services — of being “sock puppets” for the pharmaceutical industry.
On his plans for the department to create its own journals, Kennedy said they would “become the preeminent journals, because if you get [NIH] funding, it is anointing you as a good, legitimate scientist.”
Adam Gaffney, a public health researcher and an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School, wrote in an email that “banning NIH-funded researchers from publishing in leading medical journals and requiring them to publish only in journals that carry the RFK Jr. seal of approval would delegitimize taxpayer-funded research.”
He said that drug approvals are based on sound science, and that while steps should be taken to ensure that commercial interests don’t impact “the conduct or reporting of science,” this was unlikely to happen given the Trump administration’s cuts to public health and research funding, as well as Kennedy’s own anti-vaccine views.
The podcast episode was released soon after Kennedy bypassed the CDC and declared that his department would stop recommending the coronavirus vaccine for healthy pregnant women and children.
Last week, the administration released what it called “The MAHA Report,” which challenged mainstream medical consensus on issues such as vaccines. Medical experts said some of the report’s suggestions stretched the limits of science, The Washington Post reported, while several sections of the report offered misleading representations of findings in scientific papers.
Kennedy’s remarks and the report come amid growing concern in the scientific community about Trump administration actions that have stalled or disrupted research efforts. In April, the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia sent an unusual letter to the scientific journal Chest that questioned its editorial policies, sparking free-speech concerns.
NIH funding fell by more than $3 billion between President Donald Trump’s Jan. 20 inauguration and March, compared with grants issued in the same period last year, and top universities have lost out on government funding for research.
At HHS, Kennedy has spearheaded a purge of about 20,000 federal workers, affecting virtually every arm of the department. The personnel cuts and funding freezes have prompted U.S. scientists to consider moving abroad as countries such as France, Germany, Spain and China have begun actively recruiting American researchers.
If you often open multiple tabs and struggle to keep track of them, Tabs Reminder is the solution you need. Tabs Reminder lets you set reminders for tabs so you can close them and get notified about them later. Never lose track of important tabs again with Tabs Reminder!
Try our Chrome extension today!
Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more