Opinion | Good for Google, Bad for America - The New York Times


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Google's AI Ambitions: A National Security Concern?

This opinion piece expresses concern over Google's approach to artificial intelligence (AI) development, particularly its simultaneous establishment of an AI lab in China and termination of a Pentagon contract. The author, a former investor in DeepMind (now part of Google), highlights the dual-use nature of AI, emphasizing its potential for military applications.

AI's Military Applications

The article argues that AI's power lies in its application to seemingly mundane tasks like computer vision and data analysis, making it highly valuable to militaries for intelligence gathering and cyber warfare.

Google's Actions: A Contradiction?

The author finds Google's actions contradictory and alarming. Opening an AI lab in China, where military applications are difficult to discern, while simultaneously ending a Pentagon contract, raises concerns about Google's priorities. The author cites former Defense Secretary Ash Carter, who emphasizes the opacity of military-civilian projects in China.

The Core Argument

The central argument is that Google's decisions prioritize profit over American national security. By developing AI technologies in China, Google risks contributing to a potential military advantage for China, thereby undermining American interests. The author concludes that this is not just a business decision but a strategic matter with profound national security implications.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google

A “Manhattan Project” for artificial intelligence is how Demis Hassabis, the founder of DeepMind, described his company in 2010, when I was one of its first investors. I took it as figurative grandiosity. I should have taken it as a literal warning sign, because that is how it was taken in foreign capitals that were paying close attention.

Now almost a decade later, DeepMind is the crown jewel of Google’s A.I. effort. It has been the object of intense fascination in East Asia especially since March 2016 when its AlphaGo software project beat Lee Sedol, a champion of the ancient strategic board game of Go.

Such feats notwithstanding, DeepMind, having now gone on three times longer than the original Manhattan Project, is not clearly any closer to its core goal of creating an “artificial general intelligence” that rivals or replaces humanity. But it is finally becoming clear that, as with nuclear fission before it, the first users of the machine learning tools being created today will be generals rather than board game strategists.

A.I. is a military technology. Forget the sci-fi fantasy; what is powerful about actually existing A.I. is its application to relatively mundane tasks like computer vision and data analysis. Though less uncanny than Frankenstein’s monster, these tools are nevertheless valuable to any army — to gain an intelligence advantage, for example, or to penetrate defenses in the relatively new theater of cyberwarfare, where we are already living amid the equivalent of a multinational shooting war.

No doubt machine learning tools have civilian uses, too; A.I. is a good example of a “dual use” technology. But that common-sense understanding of A.I.’s ambiguity has been strangely missing from the narrative that pits a monolithic “A.I.” against all of humanity.

A.I.’s military power is the simple reason that the recent behavior of America’s leading software company, Google — starting an A.I. lab in China while ending an A.I. contract with the Pentagon — is shocking. As President Barack Obama’s defense secretary Ash Carter pointed out last month, “If you’re working in China, you don’t know whether you’re working on a project for the military or not.”

We are having trouble retrieving the article content.Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want all of The Times? Subscribe.

Was this article displayed correctly? Not happy with what you see?

Tabs Reminder: Tabs piling up in your browser? Set a reminder for them, close them and get notified at the right time.

Try our Chrome extension today!


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device