The core issue is Mayor Adams' plan to shift NYC's 250,000 municipal retirees to Medicare Advantage, a privatized version of Medicare, aiming for cost savings. This plan is opposed by a group of retirees and some City Council members.
DC 37, representing 150,000 active city workers, initially supported the Mayor's plan. However, following Council members' introduction of a bill to maintain traditional Medicare for retirees, DC 37 took action. They rescinded their endorsement of Councilwoman Alexa Aviles and stopped donating to other council members supporting the bill.
The Council bill aims to legally mandate the city's provision of a traditional Medicare plan with city subsidies for retirees. DC 37 argues the bill lacks funding and would force active workers to pay higher premiums to subsidize it.
The Mayor's Medicare Advantage plan has faced repeated legal setbacks, with the latest appeal heading to the state's highest court.
DC 37's actions highlight the significant influence of unions in local elections and underscore the ongoing conflict between the Mayor's cost-saving efforts and the retirees' desire to retain their traditional Medicare coverage.
DC 37, the cityâs largest public sector union, has rescinded its endorsement of one City Council member and committed to stop donating to several others in retaliation for their support of a bill that would protect retired municipal workersâ access to traditional Medicare, according to records obtained by the Daily News.
The retribution is born out of a long-running effort by Mayor Adamsâ administration to shift the cityâs roughly 250,000 municipal retirees into Medicare Advantage, a privatized, cost-saving version of regular Medicare.
DC 37, which represents some 150,000 active city workers, has supported the Advantage switch â its union leaders agreeing with Adamsâ argument that it would save the city hundreds of millions of dollars each year and continue to provide retirees with adequate health coverage.
But a group of municipal retirees has so far blocked Adamsâ Advantage push in court, arguing it would water down the traditional Medicare coverage they claim theyâre entitled to by law.
Some Council members are siding with the retirees and have introduced legislation to codify into law that the city must offer retirees a traditional plan, comprised of the federal Medicare program boosted by a city-subsidized supplement.
The Council effort has infuriated DC 37 brass, and in a previously unreported March 19 meeting, union leaders took action to punish the lawmakers backing the bill, according to minutes of the confab reviewed by The News.
In the meeting, union delegates, including DC 37 boss Henry Garrido, authorized a resolution to âceaseâ donations or other political assistance to âanyâ Council members who support the bill, the minutes reveal. The minutes say the measure was greenlit âafter much discussion,â though the records donât elaborate on that point.
Additionally, the delegates approved a motion to âunendorseâ Brooklyn Councilwoman Alexa Aviles âbecause of her supportâ for the legislation, the minutes say.
Aviles, a progressive Democrat who faces multiple challengers in Juneâs Democratic primary, was first awarded DC 37âs endorsement during her 2021 campaign. She didnât return a Friday request for comment.
The DC 37 move comes after Garrido in 2023 privately threatened to âwithdraw supportâ from any Council members supporting the bill, as first reported by The News. DC 37 is hugely influential in local elections and known to contribute generously to its endorsed candidates, and launch rigorous get-out-the-vote efforts for them.
Council records show the bill has 15 co-sponsors, including both Democrats and Republicans. City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, whose mayoral run was endorsed by DC 37 last month, hasnât signed on to the bill and her support would likely be required for it to move.
The minutes from the DC 37 meeting slam the bill, penned by Manhattan Councilman Chris Marte, for failing to âidentify a single source of fundingâ to bankroll the continuation of traditional Medicare for retirees.
Due to surging health care costs, the minutes say DC 37 leaders fear if the bill becomes law, active duty city workers would lose their free health care and have to âpay premiums of up $1,500â in order to subsidize the retireesâ plans.
Marianne Pizzitola, an ex-FDNY EMS who leads the retiree group that has blocked the mayorâs plan in court, called DC 37âs retaliation against Council members âdisappointing.â
âBut it is also consistent with their âthrow the retirees under the busâ posture,â she said.
The beef over the Council bill aside, courts have repeatedly blocked Adamsâ administration from implementing the Advantage plan. His administration has appealed the matter to the stateâs highest court, which is expected to hear arguments later this month.
Originally Published: May 9, 2025 at 4:34 PM EDT
If you often open multiple tabs and struggle to keep track of them, Tabs Reminder is the solution you need. Tabs Reminder lets you set reminders for tabs so you can close them and get notified about them later. Never lose track of important tabs again with Tabs Reminder!
Try our Chrome extension today!
Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more