Carney unable to find permanent chief of staff after courting high-profile candidates - The Globe and Mail


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Challenges in Finding a Permanent Chief of Staff

Prime Minister Mark Carney faces difficulty in appointing a permanent chief of staff. Several high-profile candidates, including Gerald Butts, Cyrus Reporter, and Marc-André Blanchard, declined the offer.

Interim Appointment Extended

Marco Mendicino will continue as interim chief of staff until the end of June's parliamentary session. This extension allows for continued search efforts for a suitable candidate with extensive experience.

The Importance of the Chief of Staff Role

The chief of staff plays a crucial role in providing stability and influencing government policy, particularly for a new administration. The position requires significant experience and a willingness to dedicate significant time and effort.

Potential Candidates and Current Situation

Mathieu Bouchard, a former advisor to Justin Trudeau, is being considered. The PMO is simultaneously selecting chiefs of staff for cabinet ministers, with announcements expected soon. The lack of a permanent chief of staff has led to several senior advisors only taking on short-term positions.

Concerns and Observations

The absence of a permanent chief of staff has already caused some issues, as evidenced by ministers speaking on matters outside their portfolios. The chief of staff's role in ensuring bureaucratic implementation of government policy and advising ministers is highlighted. The article also details the importance of open communication within the caucus, citing differences between current and previous practices.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google
Open this photo in gallery:Prime Minister Mark Carney departs his office ahead of a cabinet meeting in Ottawa on May 20.Spencer Colby/The Canadian Press

Prime Minister Mark Carney has been unable to find a permanent chief of staff, and is keeping former cabinet minister Marco Mendicino in the government’s top political job only until the end of June, two sources say.

A number of senior Liberals, including Justin Trudeau’s former principal secretary Gerald Butts, veteran ministerial chief of staff Cyrus Reporter and former United Nations ambassador Marc-AndrĂ© Blanchard, were approached to take on the job but declined, according to the sources.

Mr. Carney has since decided to keep Mr. Mendicino as interim chief of staff until the end of the June parliamentary session as the search continues for someone with the breadth of experience to handle the position‘s onerous responsibilities.

The Globe and Mail is not identifying the two sources, who were not authorized to discuss internal staffing.

In a statement on social media late Thursday, Mr. Carney said he asked Mr. Mendicino to remain as his top manager in the Prime Minister’s Office through the busy month ahead.

“As we prepare for the Throne Speech, I have asked Mr. Mendicino to stay into the summer in order to support the launch of the government’s mandate in Parliament and to lead the transition of the PMO on my behalf. I am grateful that he has agreed to do so,” he said.

Mr. Carney made no mention of when he would name a full-time chief of staff. He tweeted the statement after The Globe made inquiries about Mr. Mendicino leaving the PMO this summer.

Marco Mendicino, who had originally planned to return to Toronto following his tenure as an MP and Minister, agreed to serve as my initial Chief of Staff during the intense period following the Liberal leadership race, during the federal election, and the subsequent transition to


— Mark Carney (@MarkJCarney) May 22, 2025

The position of permanent chief of staff is one of the most important jobs in politics. A chief of staff provides stability, particularly for a government with a new leader and an ambitious agenda. The individual has great influence over ministers, caucus and the bureaucracy, as both a motivator and an enforcer of government policy.

One of the two sources said that Mathieu Bouchard, a former top adviser to Mr. Trudeau, has not ruled out taking on the job.

Tom Pitfield, who oversaw the Liberal election campaign along with Mr. Butts and campaign manager Andrew Bevan, is interim principal secretary but he is also not expected to stay past June.

The government has also begun selecting chiefs of staff for cabinet ministers, the sources said, and those names are expected to be released next week. The list is being overseen by the PMO.

The lack of a permanent chief of staff makes it difficult to permanently fill top positions in the PMO, as a number of senior people, such as foreign-policy adviser Scott Gilmore, only signed on for short-term stints until the election was over. Other experienced Liberals may not wish to join the PMO until they know who they will be working under as chief of staff.

Open this photo in gallery:Carney has decided to keep former cabinet minister Marco Mendicino as interim chief of staff.Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press

One of the Prime Minister’s conditions is that he wants a chief of staff who would be willing to serve for several years in a job that is quite demanding, the sources said.

“It is really a 24-7 job,” said Senator Percy Downe, who served as chief of staff to former prime minister Jean ChrĂ©tien.

“They are an extension of the prime minister, so when they pick up the phone and call somebody, they are not calling for a chat. They are calling for a specific purpose, which is to move the government’s agenda, to correct any errors that a minister may have made and to get them back on track on what the prime minister ran on in the election.”

The two sources noted that the lack of a strong chief of staff was evident last week when several ministers spoke on issues that had nothing to do with their portfolios.

Canadian Identity Minister Steven Guilbeault, for example, told reporters that there was no need for additional oil pipelines because the Trans Mountain pipeline is working under capacity. His comments caused a stir in Western Canada, particularly from Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe.

A key job of the chief of staff is to make sure the federal bureaucracy implements the government’s agenda.

“Those items that the public service supports in the government’s platform will be enthusiastically endorsed and implemented,” Mr. Downe said. “Those items that they may not be as keen on require the PMO, working with the minister, to implement a bring forward list: ‘Where are we on that? Have the target dates been met? If not, why not?’ ”

The chief of staff also advises ministers on proposals that could have a negative political impact in various regions of the country.

The chief of staff and Clerk of the Privy Council, the top bureaucrat, sit in on cabinet meetings along with the prime minister. Usually, the chief of staff is not allowed to attend national caucus meetings.

Under Mr. Trudeau, however, chief of staff Katie Telford attended caucus meetings, which Mr. Downe said he thought was unwise as it inhibits MPs from speaking out.

Under Mr. Chrétien, no staff were allowed into caucus so MPs and senators could freely tell the prime minister what they thought the government was doing well or badly.

Mr. Downe said he would be debriefed on what went on by the national caucus chair, who would never share names of MPs who were critical of the government.

“So people felt free to speak and their comments either positively or negative would come to me but I would not know who said them,” he said.

Was this article displayed correctly? Not happy with what you see?

Tabs Reminder: Tabs piling up in your browser? Set a reminder for them, close them and get notified at the right time.

Try our Chrome extension today!


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device